Discord says “app” where people used to say “bot”, and the change is more than a rename. An app can do things without ever joining your server, and since user installs arrived, it can follow a person into servers that never added it. Here is how the pieces fit, with each fact from Discord’s developer docs.
App vs bot
| App | Bot user | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | The container in the developer portal | An optional member account inside an app |
| Can have commands | Yes | Commands belong to the app |
| Shows in member list | No | Yes |
| Reads events | Only through a bot or webhooks | Yes, over the Gateway |
| Scope to add it | applications.commands | bot (includes commands) |
Discord’s OAuth2 docs say the applications.commands scope lets an app add commands to a server and is included by default with the bot scope. An app added with only the commands scope has slash commands but no member in your list.
Guild install vs user install
| Guild install (0) | User install (1) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who can install | A member with Manage Server | Any user, for themselves |
| Who sees it | All members, subject to command permissions | Only the user who installed it |
| Where it works | That server, and DMs with its bot | All of that user’s servers, DMs and group DMs |
| Permissions | The bot permissions granted at install | The user’s own permissions in each place |
| Default scopes in Discord’s example | applications.commands, bot | applications.commands |
Discord’s docs give one concrete limit: where a user has no permission to send messages, a user-installed app cannot respond with a message everyone can see. And if the interaction came from a user-installed app that is not installed in the server, the app is limited to 5 follow-up messages per interaction.
What this means for server owners
- Members can use user-installed apps in your server without you adding them. Those apps act with the member’s own permissions, not more.
- Moderation, roles, verification and backups still need a guild install with a bot user.
- If an app supports both, its Discord install link lets the person choose.
What this means for builders
- Set
integration_typeson commands to choose where they appear, andcontexts(GUILD 0, BOT_DM 1, PRIVATE_CHANNEL 2) to choose surfaces. - Discord allows 100 global slash commands, 15 user commands and 15 message commands per app, per the application commands docs.
- Use guild commands while testing: they update instantly.
How to tell what you are looking at
- It shows in your member list: it was installed to the server with a bot user.
- Its commands show up but it is not in the member list: it was added with the commands scope only, or someone is using it as a user install.
- It answers in your server but nobody remembers adding it: a member installed it to their own account.
To review what is installed in your server, open Server Settings, then Integrations. User installs belong to the member who added them.